To, Date;
05.12.2016
The
Chief Justice & Brother Judges of Supreme Court of India,
New
Delhi.
Sub;
INDIA SPEAKS
Ref;
CJI Thakur; “Process of appointment of judges cannot be 'hijacked'”
Sir,
Following
are comments from various individual readers on “Times of India” – these
comments can still be seen at link given at end;
This
CJI must go soon. He is such a mediocre person unfit to occupy the office of
the CJI. The five judge bench delivering a verdict in its own favour is a
farce. This is elementary knowledge. The judges sitting there in the supreme
court acted like simpletons. Thieves are appointing policemen. That is what the
collegium is. This silly and substandard system of appointing judges must go.
The people of India must have a say in appointing their servants called supreme
court judges. This court by itself cannot appoint its own judges. THIS
ARRANGEMENT IS NOTHING BUT GARBAGE.
Dump
this Idiot first! Looks like the last of the Congress stooges! Cancel his
pension also!
BTW,
you guys are not playing any role. You guys run most corrupt organization. So
many cases pending but you have enough time to deal with issues of BCCI and
Salman Khan!!
Mr
CJI learn English; Legislature is not executive; Article 217 of constitution of
India states; “Every Judge of a High Court shall be appointed by the President
by warrant under his hand and seal after consultation with the Chief Justice of
India, the Governor of the State, and, in the case of appointment of a Judge
other than the chief Justice, the chief Justice of the High court,…” it give
equal power to governor of a state and legislature to appoint judges.
He
is running short of time to appoint some of his people to carryout the corrupt
legacy of the collegium system. but the government is waiting for his exit on
4th Jan 2017.
Judiciary
needs to be independent true but transparent as well.
It's
high time, we need a judiciary accountable to parliament and people.
we don't want to have a self selecting and self promoting judiciary.
This
CJI cannot even make his own collegium process transparent, and he talks about
other branches of the Govt?
Don’t
do it again.. Its not the age for tears.. you should spend time with your grand
children.. Millions of cases are pending.. many people don''t live to witness
final verdict of their cases.. please let some one help judiciary to bring down
pending cases..
CJI
Thakur is always on collision course with government. Judiciary has hijacked
the appointment of judges. Lot of malpractices is going on which everyone
knows. Favouritism and nepotismis is rampant in their appointment.
Never
heard from CJI Thakur any comment on transparency in appointment of judges .
Why cannot he say publicly why a person is suitable or not for appointment as
judge of HC or SC . Also govt must disclose to the public the names of
individuals who they think is not found suitable, for elevation to HC/SC bench
l with reasons thereof . It is grossly unfair on the part of SC to preach for
transparency to others and not practise the same.
Grt..
Demi god judges want independence.. and want to screw govt and BCCI alike n
take the whole country for a ride.. hon'ble judges most corrupt rascals with no
accountability to the people the country n no checks n balances on them...
come-on u bullies India is awakening give us a break now.
This
corrupt, subversive CJI ought to be removed. His statements smack of his
dubious character and intent unworthy of a top post.
Get
on with it stop talking we the public want are cases finalized soon. We don’t
want corrupt judge.
Mr.
CJI, Your Judiciary, Media, Bureaucracy, educational institutions, Police
dept., Public works, minority institutions etc etc have already been hijacked
by commies, khangress & sickulars and are causing immense corrosion to our
system. Now when the correction is happening, you are cunningly shedding
crocodile tears to mislead the general public. Shame on you who has brought
disgrace to this noble and respected area.
This
CJI Thakur looks like power hungry and stopped working. Cases are in basement
box for 15 year.
LET
US CONSIDER AN IMAGINARY SITUATION. SUPPOSE PARLIAMENT IMPEACHES THIS CJI .
WILL CJI AND SC THEN SIT ON JUDGMENT AND RULE PARLIAMENTARY VERDICT AS NULL AND
VOID. SOONER WE GET RID OF THIS CJI THE BETTER.
another
drameybaaz
Judiciary
is the most corrupt institution in India and needs a complete reform. This CJI
is totally undeserving and should be shunned by the media.
THIS
UNELECTED SC-THAKUR HAS A GUTTER MOUTH, CAN NOOT CONTROL HIS MOUTH... I THINK
HE IS CAUGHT IN SOME KIND OF GUILT, THEREFORE HIS RUMBLING ALL THE TIME, TRYING
TO BE AGGRESSIVE.
It’s
not your father’s legacy judges should be selected from All India Entrance
exam, not from your Family.
This
is dictatorship by 5 unelected Judges, not accountable to anyone. There is no
country in the world where Judges keep on appointing themselves.
In
democracy, there has to be accountability to People. This is no absolute power
grab by 5 unelected Judges of the Supreme Court.
Mr
Thakur, first put your judiciary house in order. In plain words first act on
the corrupt judges in rural areas . If you can do this then speak for high
courts and finally for supreme court .
So
far you were independent...how come the emergency happened...how many political
cases have you solved or for that matter how many cases in 70 years were filed
and how many have got the verdict...please elaborate.
THIS
FOOOOOL FORGOT, HE AND ENTIRE SC ARE UNELECTED . ...... Someone send him a
reminding memo. This guy is beyond outrageous, he is a DUMB corrupt.
Judiciary
is acting like illuminati of middle ages who is not accountable to anyone. May
be u are the most honest person on earth but as an individual ,how can u know
from a heap of judges who is to be promoted and why and secondly once u are
gone what is the surety the new collegium with new CJI shall be one of the best
judges. Do not judge urself. let others and judiciary decide what is good for
the country.
THIS
THAKUR GUY IS A H1TLER. ..... HE JUST WANTS HIS WAY THROUGH EVERYTHING, AND HE
IS NOOOT EVEN ELECTED.
Stop
ur crocodile tears. Ur's the worst appointment as of date.
SUCH
WORDS FROM SC........... DISGUSTING, DEPLORABLE, THIS THAKUR HAS NOOO SHAME,
HE IS DRAGGING SC CLASS THROUGH GUTTERS.
Existing
mind set of Judges must go. Now people are more and more educated so
transparency must prevail upon appointment of Judges in HC/SC. Both parties
that are fighting now for Judges appointment must arrive at conclusion for
Judges. appointment quickly as backlogs in Courts are mounting. Tit for tat
policy of judiciary and parliament must end forthwith. People of India need speedy
justice delivery system in place.
Transparency
in the collegium process and appointment of judges is the need of the day to
address corruption in the judiciary. You could not handle sexual harassment
charges against one of your own. What a shame!
These
judges backed by Congress will not support judicial reforms which this
government is trying to do.
This
Thakur fella is a very tricky, slippery fish, playing politics with SC
POSITION... SC WAS NOT MEANT TO BE POLITICAL.
35
days to go. I am sometime confused as to whether the statements are made by TS
Thakur or Kapil Sibbal.
Collegium
system is a legacy of the Raj when Britishers wanted to make sure only their
chosen people became judges, without question. Its time for a change.
Correction:
The process has already been hijacked . Govt is trying to retrieve at least
part of it ! CJI has become another Khujliwal in trying to mislead the public.
Will he dare to debate the issue in public instead making these one sided
comments. Where else in the world is this Collegium System ? It appears that
after demonetization the Justitutes are more desperate to recoup the losses!
Election
commission is also independent, but selection is through executive body only.
same is with CVC etc. even RBI gov is so.
The
collegium system has too much secrecy. Nobody knows the reason for acceptance
or rejection. It''s simple - Supreme court judges should NOT appoint Supreme
Court judges.
CJI
means judges will dictate and govt should follow in selection of judges.
Current supreme court judges are thugs.
I
think MODI knows about Thakur CORRUPT LINK UP WITH SCAMGRESS LOOOTERS DYNASTY,
and Thakur knows that MODI Knows his mind.. That is why Thakurs strange, sudden
GUTTER MOUTH OPENING FILLED WITH GUILT.. MODI doesn't want to insult INSULT
Indian national institutions like SC, RBI it will hurt INDIA.. That's why MODI
LET CROOK ILL INTENT Rajan exit in time, that's why MODI letting CROOK ILL
INTENT Thakur exit in time too..
Judge's
are appointed by the judiciary in a opaque manner. How many good senior lawyers
without any godfather has reached just like our Present CJI
This
is really stupid of judiciary. They are running this collegium cartel based on
three of their own judgements!! People across world laugh at this and it
happens no where ! This a&&hole thakur is an adamant fellow.
India
is suffering Because of your bad and delayed judgment...
He
has gone berserk. Wants more judges just to strengthen his lobby. Has done
absolutely nothing to speed up disposal of already piled up cases in various
courts. Rather, is making subversive statements against the Govt. Needs to be
removed instantly.
Yes
it cannot be hijacked by the opaque collegium system.
No
hope for the Judiciary to improve as long as people like Mr.Thakur is the chief
justice. These people are selected based on their caste, creed, religion and
not on merit and hence we have to see such unfit people adoring the judiciary.
Executive
& Legislature both are answerable to "we, the people of india",
for if they do not come good on our expectations and their promises they shall
be replaced/shown the door by the people. However, judiciary is answerable to
whom??? The Balance of Power, which is considered to be the backbone of a
healthy democracy, is being totally sabotage and taken for a toss by the
judiciary. It is astonishing that not a single country in this world has a
system where the elected and representative government does not have a say in
the appointment of judges in the higher judiciary and on the other hand judges
are appointing themselves, which is nothing but a big slap in the face of our
constitution and mockery of democracy. This system of judges appointing judges
is self evolved by the judiciary and does not find any mention in our
constitution. Separation of power doesn't mean that one is free to select/elect
and appoint oneself. One cannot be the judge, jury and executioner. Scrapping
the NJAC Act is the biggest setback to our democracy and constitution. It has
created a very dangerous scenario where the "Judgment Day" does not
seem to be too far when we may see India under 'Judicial
Autocracy/Dictatorship'.
I
do agree that judiciary should have autonomy and independence from the politics
of the state as laid down in the constitution. But in order that judiciary is
regarded and respected at the highest pedestal of our society the judges must
rise above and beyond all the vices of the lesser mortals, like, corruption,
nepotism, exploitation etc., Judges cannot be stooges in one way or another.
when other eminent judges and peers question the lack of transparency in the
process of selection of judges, then there must be some substance to this
observation. Therefore collegium or whatever system is adopted should have that
aura of invincibility that the body is above all the malice’s, and for its
success, if any executive is included to strengthen the system, why should
there be an erosion in the independence of judiciary ? My question is if a
Lokpal, which is no less important position than a SC or HC judge, is appointed
through a select committee comprising of members of executive and judiciary,
then, what''s wrong if the same procedure is adopted in case judges as well. I
can''t help thinking that the current CJI is equally responsible for delay in
appointment of judges as he is unable to play a positive role in bringing the
two arms of the society together.
This
guy is gone on Jan 3rd.Judiciary is not independent anywhere, not even in the
US. Judges of the Supreme Court in US are appointed by the President of USA.
Appointment
of judges in India is not transparent and judiciary is full of corrupt judges
who act as Congi agents.
Time
to boot these judges and elect new ones.
This
CONGI CJI is a shame. He is using language like Rahul PAPPU. He might start
using the words like "Dalal" and Hijack!!! What is hijacking Mr. CJI?
Have they hijacked a plane where you are a passenger? did you mean hostage
taking instead. CJI , I am disappointed in your choice of words and phrases.
Are you a CONGI?
Only
thing government can hijack is you guys at the moment, otherwise you all have
hijacked everything, in days to come judges will sit behind bullet proof
glasses. cunts
Nepotism
and strictly Seniority based Self Appointment Process is not in the
Constitution and cannot serve the interest of the Nation.
Why
so big corruption in Judiciary, when selection is by CJI and his team????
It
has already been hijacked since 1993 judgment when the callous collegium of
mama bhanjas and chacha bhatijas has to decide who the bhanja/ bhatija is next
melord and mind it the chauvinistic male never nominated a bhanji or bhatiji !
SC,
THAKUR IN PARTICULAR, LIKE RAJAN, NOW REALIZES, THEY HAVE CROSSED IT'S LIMITS
ON MANY INSTANCES, IS FEELING GUILT, THEREFORE, GUTTER MOUTH CAN NOOT STAY
SHUT.... THAKURS GUILT IS TOOO VISIBLE EVERYTIME HE OPENS HIS MOUTH WHERE IT'S
UNCALLED FORE.. .. .. THAKUR IS UNELECTED... SOMEONE SEND HIM A REMINDER NOTE,
HE IS UNELECTED..
Gabbar
singh has no respect for parliament. NJAC bill was vetoed by this Gabbar singh.
As
per Doctrine of Separation of Powers, the appointment of Judges of High Court
& Supreme Court is job of Executive. Once appointed there is no
interference in working of judiciary by Executive. Judiciary can not run a
parallel government. It should know the Laxman Rekha.
Against
vacancies of 500 judges, CJI recommends just 43 names of those facing charges
or complaints of corruption and yet CJI says govt is locking out judges.
With
due respect to the CJI TS Thakur, I strongly disagree with him. People
occupying position of responsibility will be judged, not institution. Hence TS
Thakur should stop casting aspersions on the executive & glorifying the
Judiciary. It is such acts by individuals which eventually demeans a
institution & erodes it's credibility. Seems like TS Thakur will take down
the judiciary along with him.
I
should also make make it clear were judges appointed before advent of self
styled collegium system were not independent while functioning as judges.
Constitution provides for appointment of Judges by President of India in
consultation with C.J.I . It does not provide for collegium system. Other
constitutional authorities like C.E.C , C.A.G etc are also appointed by
government but they are fully independent in their functioning. Mere appointment
of Judges by collegium will not make them independent and independent from
other pressures so long as judge himself does not go for that. C.J.i is simply
politicizing the issue. He should behave in more dignified manner.
They
took this authority forcefully in the 90s and now say that this can not be
hijacked.. Logic is missing.
Mind
set of judges needs a change. They are not supreme .
Judges
want to be player and also umpire the acrimony between the two pillars of nation
is very disturbing for common man.
It's
the prerogative of the elected members of the parliament to appoint the members
of the judiciary and that in no way takes away the independence of it. The
government does not tell the judges how to make decisions. This is what is done
in many Western democratic countries. It's utter nonsense on the part of the
judiciary to insist on appointing judges by them with the excuse of keeping
judiciary independent. It only creates an institution unrepresented and unelected
by people and not answerable to the people. Shame on them. Indian judiciary has
a very poor reputation. Let the government go ahead with its policy. After all
the members of the government are elected by people unlike the members of the
judiciary.
How
can judges appoint judges!! There has to be some transparency...
Rahul
talks about "HACKING". - CJI talks about "HIJACKING". - Any
similarity between the two?
This
man Mr.Thakur is just a total misfit for the post of Chief justice of India.
This
asshols will keep on lecturing or do something.?
Oh,
he is retiring shortly! That explains the hurry to post near and dear!
Surely
the learned judge knows that the NJAC has both the judiciary and executive
jointly selecting candidates. If only the judiciary were to elect their own
where is oversight and best interests of the people represented? Atleast people
can elect and not elect or impeach parliamentarians. But who can dis endorse
corrupt judges? The judiciary are acting like high priests.
These
average mind people takes years n years for a case.. give judgement... which is
overturned by higher courts... same books... same evidences... different
verdicts.... should they b above d elected govt... no... bt transparency in
selection is must...
A
surgical strike should be done on judiciary to reveal their corruption.
Big
talk justifying an unconstitutional action. we are governed not by a set of
persons but by the Constitution of India. He should read the relevant
provisions of the constitution of India. if he did not understand, he should
ask his grand son to read them and explain to him. He will then understand how
blatantly the SC has violated the provisional of the constitution. So
scornfully aside the unanimous decision of the pillar of Democracy, the Parliament
and several legislatures of the states, exactly in accordance with the
provisions of the Constitution is in itself an act of contempt of the august
body, the Parliament. If power of appointment of successors in office is an
indication of independence, the Attorney general, auditor general, the IAS/IPS
etc should all be empowered to nominate the holders of similar office.
SC-THAKUR
TOTALLY FORGOT IT'S ROLE, IT'S LIMITS, THAKUR FORGOT, SC BUNCH ARE UNELECTED,
AND ARE TRYING TO RUN PARALLEL EXECUTIVE GOV.... WORSE, THAKUR HAS SOME SHADY
LOOTERS SCAMGRESS DYNASTY LINKS??
CJI
Thakur, YOU ARE A FRAUD, AND SOO BRAZENLY YOU ARE FRAUD... YOU ARE BRINGING
DOWN THE CLASSY NAME OF SC....... STEP DOWN IMMEDIATELY.
Chief
Justice of India T S Thakur''s speech makes it clear that the judiciary is not
prepared for any changes in the procedure for recruitment of judges. There are
no two opinions that all is not well with the present system of selecting
judges. The SC collegium itself is divided on the issue. There is no
transparency in the recruitment of judges. Both the government and the
collegium are equally responsible for delays in filling up the large scale
vacancies both in SC and High Courts. With the differences widening between the
government and the judiciary, the common man continues to suffer, which is most
unfortunate. There is a need to study the systems prevailing in the major
democracies of the world on selection of judges and adopt which is most suitable
to India. The present situation should not continue for too long.
Many Indians
feels that Judiciary is most corrupt and incompetent organization in today.
Kindly do something (recommend impeachment of few some corrupt Judges the black sheep in Judiciary) to improve its image.
For
information and necessary action.
K
D Aggarwal,
Advocate.
No comments:
Post a Comment